Skip to main content

Search

Consumer Banking and Payments Law: 11.2.6.1 General

While E-Sign applies to all federal writing requirements (such as consumer disclosures),76 it specifically excludes certain writings from its coverage, including important notices that are required to alert consumers to potential losses of important rights (such as cancellation of utility services, default on a mortgage contract or an eviction, or cancellation of health or life insurance).77

Consumer Banking and Payments Law: 11.2.6.2 Court Documents and Government Filings

E-Sign and UETA exclude court documents, including records relating to court orders or notices or official court documents required to be executed in connection with court proceedings. Briefs, pleadings, and “other writings” are specifically listed as among the items regarded as included under this rubric.88 This does not prevent court filings from being filed electronically; it only means that the court and not E-Sign makes that determination.89

Consumer Arbitration Agreements: 3.5.5a State Law When Defendant Refuses to Arbitrate

A California statute provides significant rights to consumers and employees when the business they are in arbitration with fails to pay initial arbitration fees, or other costs assessed on the business during the arbitration.261 The statute provides that if the business does not pay the required fees and costs to initiate an arbitration proceeding within thirty days after their due date, the business is in default and waives its right to compel arbitration.

Truth in Lending: 4.3.1 Overview

Paperless lending is a developing issue in consumer credit. While credit transactions using electronic records and electronic signatures can provide conveniences for borrowers, they also create substantial opportunities for fraud.

Truth in Lending: 4.3.2 Authority of the CFPB to Interpret Electronic Disclosure Standards and Establish Exceptions

Federal agencies have authority to interpret E-Sign, but the interpretation must be consistent with the statute’s rules for electronic disclosures and cannot add requirements.210 Agencies can set requirements for electronic disclosures only if they are substantially equivalent to the requirements for nonelectronic disclosures and do not impose unreasonable costs on acceptance and use of electronic records.211 Agencies also cannot require the application of a specific technology or technical spec

Truth in Lending: 4.3.9 Manner of Delivering Electronic Notices

E-Sign does not address how electronic information should be delivered, except to say that states that pass UETA cannot circumvent the federal statute by imposing nonelectronic delivery methods. As a result, delivery methods required by TILA and Regulation Z remain in effect. While TILA’s language about how disclosures must be made was written without electronic means of transmission in mind, it still provides some safeguards.262

Truth in Lending: 4.3.10 Penalties for Violation of Electronic Disclosure Safeguards

One subsection of the provision on E-Sign consent provides that the legal effectiveness, validity, or enforceability of a consumer contract shall not be denied solely because of the failure to obtain electronic consent or confirmation of consent.266 This language only means the failure to obtain E-Sign consent is not in and of itself sufficient to undermine the validity of the underlying contract.

Truth in Lending: 4.4.1 Why Timing Matters

The statute requires that closed-end disclosures be made “before the credit is extended.”271 Regulation Z uses the phrase “before consummation.”272 The requirement is important because the disclosures are supposed to guide the consumer in making a rational economic choice about the financial attractiveness of the transaction prior to entering into it, and to facilitate comparison shopping.273

Truth in Lending: 4.4.2 When Must the Disclosures Be Made?

While special timing rules have been added to TILA over the years requiring the delivery of disclosures at specific times,278 the general rule is that disclosures handed to the consumer even one second before consummation meet TILA’s requirement that the disclosures be delivered pre-consummation.279 Nonetheless, many creditors fail to deliver the documents until after consummation.280

Truth in Lending: 4.4.3 Special Timing Rules

Special timing rules that apply in closed-end consumer credit transactions secured by real property and subject to the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act—and those governed by the TILA-RESPA integrated disclosure regime since October 3, 2015—are discussed at § 4.4.7, infra.287 Special timing rules for adjustable-rate mortgages are discussed at

Truth in Lending: 4.4.4.1 General

Consummation is defined as “the time that a consumer becomes contractually obligated on a credit transaction.”289 For there to be consummation for TILA purposes, the consumer must be “legally obligated to accept a particular credit arrangement.”290 Whether—or when—a consumer becomes contractually and legally obligated is an issue of state law.291

Truth in Lending: 4.4.4.2 Financial Investment May Not Be Enough for Consummation

The thrust of the official interpretations is that there is consummation when the creditor could successfully sue the consumer for breach of contract if the consumer defaulted on the terms. It is not enough that the consumer has made a psychological or financial investment in the transaction from which there is no return, “unless, of course, applicable law holds otherwise.”297 The example of such an investment in the official interpretations is the payment of a nonrefundable fee.